Some rivalries are settled in a single night. The great ones are not. A trilogy is boxing's answer to an argument that refuses to end: the same two men, three meetings, each one rewriting what the last one meant. One fight can be a fluke. Three fights leave nowhere to hide. Each fight changes the next. Across eight trilogies — twenty-five fights in all — these are the rivalries that defined boxing.
“It was like death. Closest thing to dyin' that I know of.”
1. Muhammad Ali vs Joe Frazier — Ali 2–1
The first meeting, 8 March 1971 at Madison Square Garden, was the Fight of the Century. Frazier (26-0) beat Ali (31-0) by 15-round unanimous decision to retain the WBA and WBC heavyweight titles — the first time two undefeated fighters had met for the heavyweight title. Scores: Mercante 8-6-1, Aidala 9-6, Recht 11-4. Frazier floored Ali with a left hook in round 15, and Ali suffered his first professional defeat. Purses were $2.5 million each, unprecedented.
The second, 28 January 1974, again at Madison Square Garden, was a 12-rounder for the NABF title — not a world title, because George Foreman held the championships. Ali won by unanimous decision: Perez 6-5-1, Castellano 7-4-1, Gordon 8-4. Ali weighed 212 lb, Frazier 209 lb.
The third, the "Thrilla in Manila", 1 October 1975 at the Araneta Coliseum in Quezon City, was Ali's fourth defence of the WBA and WBC titles he had won from Foreman in 1974. It began at about 10:45 a.m. local time. After 14 rounds, Frazier's trainer Eddie Futch stopped it: "Sit down, son. It's all over. No one will forget what you did here today." Ali won by TKO on a retirement. Afterwards Ali said: "It was like death. Closest thing to dyin' that I know of." And: "We went to Manila as champions, Joe and me, and we came back as old men."
2. Arturo Gatti vs Micky Ward — Gatti 2–1
The first fight, 18 May 2002 at Mohegan Sun in Uncasville, was a 10-round junior welterweight non-title fight. Ward (37-11) beat Gatti (34-5) by majority decision, both men weighing 142 lb. Scores: Flaherty 94-93, Weisfeld 95-93, Lombardi 94-94. Gatti was docked a point in round 4 for a low blow. In round 9, Ward dropped Gatti with a body left hook, Gatti survived and fired back, Ward landed 60 power punches to Gatti's 42, and there was not a single clinch. The round is widely regarded as one of the greatest ever fought. The fight was the Ring's Fight of the Year for 2002 and the Boxing Writers Association of America Fight of the Year; round 9 was the Ring's Round of the Year.
The rematch, 23 November 2002 at Boardwalk Hall in Atlantic City — not Mohegan Sun — went to Gatti by unanimous decision. He floored Ward in round 3 with an overhand right that ruptured Ward's eardrum. Scores: 98-91, 98-91, 98-90.
The third, 7 June 2003, again at Boardwalk Hall, was Gatti's again by unanimous decision, 96-93, 96-93, 97-92. Ward knocked Gatti down in round 6, at the bell, and Gatti fought on with a broken right hand, injured in round 4. Both men went to hospital afterwards. It was the Ring's Fight of the Year for 2003. Ward, 37, retired after the third fight. The two men became close friends, and Ward later trained Gatti. Gatti died in 2009, aged 37.
3. Marco Antonio Barrera vs Erik Morales — Barrera 2–1
The first fight, 19 February 2000 at the Mandalay Bay in Las Vegas, was a super bantamweight unification: Morales's WBC title against Barrera's WBO title. Morales beat Barrera by 12-round split decision, 115-112, 114-113, 113-114, and captured the WBO title. It was the Ring's Fight of the Year for 2000, with round 5 named Round of the Year. The decision was disputed: Barrera scored the only knockdown of the fight, in round 12, when Morales went down on a knee for a 10-8 round — and still lost. Judges: Ford 114-113 Barrera, Castellano 114-113 Morales, Shirley 115-112 Morales. Afterwards Morales moved up to featherweight, and the WBO "ignored the judges' decision and let Barrera keep his title."
The rematch, 22 June 2002 at the MGM Grand Garden Arena, went to Barrera by unanimous decision, 116-112, 115-113, 115-113, for the WBC and vacant Ring featherweight titles. Barrera won the Ring title, retained the lineal championship, and declined the WBC title, which became vacant. Disputed again: HBO's Harold Lederman had it 115-113 for Morales. Morales entered 41-0; Barrera was 54-3.
The third, 27 November 2004 at the MGM Grand, was at super featherweight. Barrera won by majority decision, 115-113, 115-114, 114-114, taking the WBC super featherweight title. It was the Ring's Fight of the Year for 2004.
4. Manny Pacquiao vs Juan Manuel Marquez — Pacquiao 2–1–1
Strictly speaking, this is not a trilogy at all. Pacquiao and Marquez fought four times — a tetralogy that kept producing fights too close and too controversial to leave alone. Pacquiao leads it 2-1-1 across four fights and 42 rounds.
The first, 8 May 2004 at the MGM Grand Garden Arena, was a 12-round split draw, 115-110 Pacquiao, 115-110 Marquez, 113-113, for the WBA (Unified), IBF and Ring featherweight titles. Pacquiao dropped Marquez three times in round 1. The draw turned on a scoring error: judge Burt Clements scored round 1 10-7 instead of 10-6. Had he scored it 10-6, Pacquiao would have won by split decision. Clements: "I dropped the ball, plainly and simply."
The second, "Unfinished Business", 15 March 2008 at the Mandalay Bay Events Center, went to Pacquiao by split decision, 115-112, 114-113 Pacquiao, 115-112 Marquez, for the WBC and vacant Ring super featherweight titles. Pacquiao knocked Marquez down once, in round 3 — and the knockdown was the difference.
The third, "The 25th Round Begins", 12 November 2011 at the MGM Grand Garden Arena, was fought at a catchweight of 144 lbs. Pacquiao won by majority decision, 114-114, 115-113, 116-112, retaining the WBO welterweight title. The crowd reaction was "largely negative with thousands continuing to boo".
The fourth, "Fight of the Decade", 8 December 2012 at the MGM Grand Garden Arena, ended it. Marquez knocked Pacquiao out at 2:59 of round 6 with a right hand, Pacquiao falling face-first, and referee Kenny Bayless did not count. Marquez had dropped Pacquiao in round 3; Pacquiao had dropped Marquez in round 5, and after five rounds Pacquiao was ahead 47-46 on all three cards. No title was at stake — a 147-lb non-title fight — and the winner received the WBO's commemorative "Champion of the Decade" belt. It was the Ring's Fight of the Year and Knockout of the Year for 2012.
5. Riddick Bowe vs Evander Holyfield — Bowe 2–1
The first fight, 13 November 1992 at the Thomas & Mack Center in Las Vegas, saw Bowe win by unanimous decision, 115-112, 117-110, 117-110, taking Holyfield's lineal, WBA, WBC and IBF titles. It was the Ring's Fight of the Year. Both men were undefeated, and Holyfield fought with a 30-pound weight disadvantage.
The second, 6 November 1993 at Caesars Palace, went to Holyfield by majority decision, 115-113, 115-114, 114-114, and he reclaimed the WBA and IBF titles. In round 7, paraglider James Miller — "Fan Man" — crashed into the ring, and referee Mills Lane called time with 1:54 left in the round. The delay lasted about twenty minutes while Miller was beaten unconscious by fans and security and removed on a stretcher, and Bowe's wife Judy fainted and was taken away by ambulance. Miller: "It was a heavyweight fight and I was the only guy who got knocked out." It was the Ring's Event of the Year for 1993.
The third, 4 November 1995 at Caesars Palace, billed "The Final Chapter", was a non-title fight — Bowe held the WBO title, but it was not at stake. Bowe won by TKO at 0:58 of round 8, referee Joe Cortez stopping it. Holyfield had led 66-65 on all three cards after seven rounds, and in round 6 his left hook had floored Bowe, the first knockdown of Bowe's professional career. Bowe then dropped Holyfield twice in round 8, the first stoppage loss of Holyfield's career. Bowe had a point deducted for a low blow in round 5. Weights: Bowe 240 lb, Holyfield 213 lb. Both men were paid $8 million.
6. Sugar Ray Leonard vs Roberto Duran — Leonard 2–1
The first fight, 20 June 1980 at the Olympic Stadium in Montreal — "The Brawl in Montreal" — went to Duran by 15-round unanimous decision, 145-144, 148-147, 146-144, winning the WBC welterweight title. It was Leonard's first professional defeat. The result was first announced as a majority decision, because judge Angelo Poletti's card had been wrongly tallied at 147-147, and was then corrected to unanimous. Crowd: 46,317. Leonard entered 27-0, Duran 71-1. Weights: Leonard 145 lb, Duran 146 lb.
The second, 25 November 1980 at the Louisiana Superdome in New Orleans, is the "No Mas" fight. Leonard won by TKO at 2:44 of round 8, regaining the WBC welterweight title. In the closing seconds of round 8, Duran turned his back, waved his glove, and said to referee Octavio Meyran, "No mas". Howard Cosell: "What! Duran has quit! Roberto Duran has quit!" Leonard led 68-66, 68-66, 67-66 at the stoppage. What Duran actually said is still disputed: in ESPN's "No Mas" documentary, Duran said he did not say "No Mas" and that Cosell "made that up", while referee Meyran insisted that Duran did say it.
The third, 7 December 1989 at the Mirage in Las Vegas — "Uno Mas" — saw Leonard retain the WBC super-middleweight title by unanimous decision, 120-110, 119-109, 116-111. Leonard was 33, Duran 38; the contracted limit was 162 lb, Leonard weighing 160 lb, Duran 158 lb. Only Leonard's super-middleweight title was at stake. Duran had won the WBC middleweight title from Iran Barkley in February 1989, and this was Leonard's second defence since drawing with Thomas Hearns in June 1989. Punch numbers: Leonard landed 227 of 438, 118 of them jabs; Duran landed 84 of 588, 33 of them jabs. Duran cut Leonard over both eyes in rounds 11 and 12, and Leonard needed 60 stitches — 30 in the right eyebrow, 20 in the left eyelid, 10 in the lip. Sellout: 16,305. After the Duran fights, Leonard suffered a detached retina and was inactive for nearly three years before beating Marvin Hagler in 1987; in November 1988 he beat Donny Lalonde for the WBC light-heavyweight and super-middleweight titles.
7. Tony Zale vs Rocky Graziano — Zale 2–1
All three fights were for the world middleweight title, and all three came inside twenty-one months. The first, 27 September 1946 at Yankee Stadium, saw Zale (160 lb) retain the title by KO in round 6 of 15, at 1:43, with a right to the body followed by a left hook. Referee: Ruby Goldstein. Zale had dropped Graziano in round 1 and been dropped himself in round 2, and he "appeared to be weakening steadily" through round 5 before the sixth-round reversal. Crowd: 39,827. Gate: $342,497. It was the Ring's Fight of the Year for 1946.
The second, 16 July 1947 at Chicago Stadium, was the mirror image. Graziano won the title by TKO in round 6 of 15, at 2:10. Referee: Johnny Behr. Zale dominated the early rounds, cut Graziano over the left eye in round 2, and nearly shut his right eye — then tired in the heat, and Graziano took him apart. Weights: Graziano 155 lb, Zale 159 lb. Crowd: 18,547. Receipts: $422,918. It was the Ring's Fight of the Year for 1947.
The third, 10 June 1948 at Ruppert Stadium in Newark, saw Zale regain the title by KO in round 3 of 15, at 1:08. A left hook dropped Graziano for a seven-count, and a second left hook to the jaw knocked him out cold. Referee: Paul Cavalier. The fight had originally been scheduled for 9 June and was postponed a day by rain. Both men weighed 159 lb, and Graziano, the defending champion, was a 12-to-5 favourite. Crowd: 21,497. Gate: $335,646. Zale became only the third man to regain the middleweight title, after Stanley Ketchel and Al Hostak. The first two fights both ended in round 6; the third ended in round 3.
8. Floyd Patterson vs Ingemar Johansson — Patterson 2–1
All three fights were for the world heavyweight title, and all three ended inside the distance. The first, 26 June 1959 at Yankee Stadium, went to Johansson by TKO in round 3 of 15, at 2:03. Patterson was floored seven times in round 3 — all seven inside 123 seconds — and referee Ruby Goldstein stopped it. The weapon was Johansson's overhand right, known as the "Hammer of Thor", "Ingo's Bingo" and "Toonder and Lightning". Patterson was so disoriented after the first knockdown that he turned toward his own corner. Johansson was 26, and he was named the Associated Press Athlete of the Year and the Sports Illustrated Sportsman of the Year for 1959.
The second, 20 June 1960 at the Polo Grounds, saw Patterson win the undisputed heavyweight championship — the NBA, NYSAC and Ring titles — by KO in round 5 of 15, at 1:51. A leaping left hook dropped Johansson for the first time in his career, and a second left hook left him out cold. Referee: Arthur Mercante Sr. Patterson became the first man in history to regain the undisputed heavyweight title; eight previous champions had tried and failed — Corbett, Fitzsimmons, Jeffries, Dempsey, Schmeling, Louis, Charles and Walcott. Patterson led 3-1 on all three cards at the stoppage. Crowd: 31,892.
The third, 13 March 1961 in Miami Beach, saw Patterson retain the title by KO in round 6 of 15, late in the sixth — a left hook, a right to the jaw and a chopping right to the ear. Referee: Bill Regan. In round 1, Johansson dropped Patterson twice, Patterson dropped Johansson once, the first time since Dempsey against Firpo in 1923 that both men had been down in round 1 of a heavyweight title fight. That first round was the Ring's 1961 Round of the Year, and the fight was the first heavyweight title fight to use the mandatory eight-count. Johansson's only two professional losses were to Patterson; his final record was 26-2 with 17 knockouts.
Why they last
Count the series: Ali 2–1, Gatti 2–1, Barrera 2–1, Pacquiao 2–1–1, Bowe 2–1, Leonard 2–1, Zale 2–1, Patterson 2–1. In five of the eight, the man who lost the first fight came back to win the series outright. Pacquiao drew his opener and still took the series. Only Bowe and Zale won the first fight and held on. One fight answers who was better on the night; three answer who was better, full stop.





