Skip to content
UFC

On This Day — November 16: St-Pierre Survives Hendricks and the Scorecards at UFC 167

November 16 is the calendar's monument to the scorecard. In 2013 it produced the most argued-over decision of the modern era — a champion battered, half-blind and amnesiac, keeping his belt by a single round on two cards — and in 2019 it did it again in miniature, in São Paulo, for a great man's last campaign. Some dates give knockouts. This one gives arguments that have never ended.

4 min read

Share
On This Day — November 16: St-Pierre Survives Hendricks and the Scorecards at UFC 167 — AI illustration
On This Day — November 16: St-Pierre Survives Hendricks and the Scorecards at UFC 167 — AI illustration

On This Day — November 16: St-Pierre Survives Hendricks and the Scorecards at UFC 167

November 16 is the calendar's monument to the scorecard. In 2013 it produced the most argued-over decision of the modern era — a champion battered, half-blind and amnesiac, keeping his belt by a single round on two cards — and in 2019 it did it again in miniature, in São Paulo, for a great man's last campaign. Some dates give knockouts. This one gives arguments that have never ended.

November 16 is the calendar's monument to the scorecard. In 2013 it produced the most argued-over decision of the modern era — a champion battered, half-blind and amnesiac, keeping his belt by a single round on two cards — and in 2019 it did it again in miniature, in São Paulo, for a great man's last campaign. Some dates give knockouts. This one gives arguments that have never ended.

2013 — The decision

UFC 167 was the promotion's 20th-anniversary show, and Georges St-Pierre arrived as its model champion: precise, risk-managed, unbeaten in eleven fights. Johny Hendricks arrived with dynamite in his left hand and a wrestler's base, and for twenty-five minutes he did what no one had done to St-Pierre — he out-damaged him. Hendricks staggered the champion with a left uppercut in the second round, mauled him with knees to the thigh in the clinch, took him down, and left his face a swollen mask. St-Pierre, to his everlasting credit, kept coming: he won rounds with volume and refusal, including a fifth round he contested like a man who knew the fight was slipping.

The cards: Sal D'Amato 48–47 St-Pierre. Tony Weeks 48–47 St-Pierre. Glenn Trowbridge 48–47 Hendricks. The champion kept his belt, and the sport split in two. Every one of the sixteen media scorecards collected afterward had the fight for Hendricks. Hendricks said what he said: "I thought I clearly won the fight." St-Pierre, astonishingly candid, said the rest himself: "Without a doubt my toughest fight. I lost memory a little bit during the fight, I couldn't see with one of my eyes. He really messed me up."

Then came the second bombshell of the night. Standing in the Octagon, still bleeding, St-Pierre announced he was stepping away — "I am going to hang my gloves up for a little bit and make sense of my life." He vacated the title within weeks. Hendricks won the empty belt the following March, and St-Pierre stayed gone for four years, until he returned at UFC 217 to become a two-division champion — which means November 16, 2013 is both the night his reign effectively ended and the hinge on which his entire legend swings: the greatest welterweight ever, beaten by the eye, saved by the arithmetic, honest enough to walk away.

2019 — Jacaré's last argument

Six years later in São Paulo, November 16 handed out another split decision to argue about. Ronaldo "Jacaré" Souza, 39 and nearing forty, moved up to light heavyweight for a final run at a UFC title, and met Jan Błachowicz in a five-round main event that never ignited: long clinch stalemates, sparse exchanges, and official totals of 71 significant strikes for Błachowicz against just 20 for Souza. Two judges gave it to the Pole, 48–47; one gave Souza the same score. "Every time it's a tough fight, a close fight, they never give me the win," Souza said — the lament of a great grappler whose career is a museum of narrow scorecards in other people's favor.

The co-main event fit the evening: Maurício "Shogun" Rua, 37, fought Paul Craig to a split draw, three judges producing three different verdicts. The night's pulse came from below: Charles Oliveira knocked out Jared Gordon in 86 seconds, his sixth straight finish, on his way to a title nobody in the building that night saw coming.

Also on this day

  • 2019, São Paulo: Renan Barão, once a pound-for-pound king, lost a unanimous decision to Douglas Silva de Andrade on the prelims — the fall, continuing in public.
  • 2019, São Paulo: Four Performance of the Night bonuses and no Fight of the Night — the judges' cards were the night's most debated performances.

A battered king keeping his crown by one round, a legend of the ground game losing one more argument with the judges: November 16 belongs to the scorecard, and the scorecard belongs to no one.

View All

REAL MMA. STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

Get the biggest stories, exclusive interviews and fight analysis. No spam.

Free
100%
Updates
Weekly